August 13, 2006

Homeland Security Should be Number One Priority

Recently hundreds of American lives were saved using surveillance tools that critics have called illegal, and threatening to our civil liberties. Realizing that one third of Newark Liberty Airport lies in Union County and that we are the home of the most dangerous two miles on the eastern seaboard, I really don’t care much who is listening to my telephone conversations.

Just a few short days ago NJ Senators stood in the Port of NY and NJ claiming that the current administration has made incompetent security choices and aren’t putting the interests of the working families first.

Well, it seems to me that if the current administration wasn’t doing their job we surely could have had a plane or two exploding over the port taking a countless number of lives on both the ground and in the air along with part of a tank farm, a cat cracker and a piece of down town Elizabeth.

With campaign rhetoric sounding like he is the new kid on the block, candidate Bob Menendez says that America needs to be given a new direction where homeland security is concerned. His buddies say he is just the guy to send to Washington to do the job of ensuring America’s interests.

Somebody please tell me what he has been doing in Washington these past eight years; shouldn’t he have been looking out for New Jersey’s interests and her hard working families?

Certainly these are dangerous times and it wouldn’t take much for Union County, as we know it, to be a fond memory. It is important that we have the best of the best giving their undivided attention to Homeland Security/Emergency Management measures ensuring that in times of crisis UC is prepared.

The Dir. of Public Safety, Harold Gibson, is a county employee earning a salary of $109,793 per year. Currently he is being considered to replace the late Plainfield Councilman Ray Blanco. Council members have the responsibility to look out for their towns during times of crisis and Mr. Gibson’s county department is also an integral part of the county’s emergency management plan, so we must question his ability to be in two places at once, should a countywide emergency occur.

The New Jersey Office of Emergency Management issues directives, “how to” guidelines, provides training courses and sets the requirements and standards for departmental workers at the county and municipal levels. The office ensures that these standards are enforced as a division of the Dept. of Law and Public Safety/Office of the Attorney General. Position descriptions on the state’s personnel website list prior emergency response experience, specialized certifications and educational levels necessary to qualify for a variety of positions in county offices of Emergency Management. Grant monies help fund these offices with qualifiers attached in some cases to insure that the grants are used as intended including the hiring of qualified employees.

The UC Division of Environmental Health and Emergency Management writes an Assessment and Improvement Plan which outlines areas of concern, progress and existing services for handling both natural and man made environmental situations in the county. Though some changes and improvements have been made since the 2004 report, more can always be done to ensure the daily safety of county residents.

Probably the single most important department of county government because it has the potential to impact on the lives of all county residents, funding should never be an issue, regulatory compliance should always be without question, staffing second to none and deployment at the ready on a moments notice.

After all isn’t providing for the health and welfare of the residents what county government is intended to do?

August 07, 2006

Union County Alliance - Let the sunshine in!!!!!

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
Date: August 10, 2006
Contact: Union County Watchdog Association, Inc.
(908)709-0530

UNION COUNTY- The states Government Records Council (GRC), the official agency which oversees the Open Public Records Act (OPRA), has ruled today that the Union County Alliance is a public agency and is thereby subject to the provisions of the OPRA.

A complaint was filed with the GRC when a request for records was denied by the Alliance. Tina Renna, on behalf of the Union County Watchdog Association, sought documents pertaining to the Union County Directions Newsletter. The Alliance is listed as the publisher. The Alliance responded that they are not a government agency and therefore as a 501(c)4 corporation they were not subject to the provisions of the OPRA.

Renna submitted documents to the GRC supporting her assertion that the Alliance is a public agency. Along with other evidence, Renna asserted that the Directions Newsletter is sent out labeled “Postal Patron” which is a distinction that only government organizations can use and provided one of these newsletters in support of this. Renna further asserted that the newsletter is produced in the County Administration Building using county employees and equipment and is mailed to every postal patron only days before the Primary and General Election Day, featuring freeholders and other politicians who are up for re-election throughout its pages.

A June 18, 2002 letter from an Executive Vice President of the Alliance to the Postmaster indicated that the County of Union and the Alliance share a postal account.

In an October 21, 2001 letter from the County of Union Department of Finance to the Union County Alliance, the Director of Finance asks that the Alliance submit their $150,000 voucher to the County Manager, outlining details of how the funds would be spent and the goals and objectives of that spending. The letter goes on to state that payment for this voucher and invoice must be approved by the freeholders before a check can be distributed.

The GRC ruled that the Open Public Meetings Act (OPMA) defines “public body” as a commission, authority, board council, committee or any other group of two or more persons organized under the laws of this State, and collectively empowered as a voting body to perform a public government function affecting the rights, duties, obligations, privileges, benefits, or other legal relations of any person, or collectively authorized to spend public funds. N.J.S.A. 10:4-8a.

The Union County Alliance is a nonprofit 501(c)4 corporation which, according to a County of Union press release, was founded in 1994 as a 501(c)3 by then County Manager Ann Baron. The Alliance’s Certificate of Incorporation lists Ann Baran and then President of Kean College Dr. Henry J. Ross as the initial incorporators, indicating a Kean College address. At the time of their filing for their nonprofit status the Alliance was operating under a grant from Union County; following an initial grant from the NJ Department of Higher Education. The Alliance currently receives 80 percent of its $300,000 annual budget from the County of Union.

In his uncertified response to Renna’s complaint Michael Murray, the Executive Director of the Alliance, claimed that the Alliance’s offices are not located within a government building and that only one employee receives salary and benefits from a government agency.

Renna was able to prove that the Alliance is located within the State’s Kean University and that an officer of the Alliance is in fact listed as a Kean employee. Murray himself is listed on the Union County Payroll with a salary of $104,000. Murray also has use of a county owned 2002 Ford Explorer.

Tina Renna, President of the Union County Watchdog Association today thanked the GRC for their ruling during the public comment portion of their board meeting and went on to state, “The Union County Alliance has been blatantly involved with the County of Union in politicking at the public’s expense and up until now only God knows what else. This GRC ruling will now give the public the right to request records pertaining to how their tax-dollars are being spent. This agency needs a good looking at and because of your ruling the public can now do just that.”
__________

View Draft Findings and Recommendations for this GRC complaint, number 2006-73 below link (final’s were not available at the time of this writing). There was only one revision to the draft findings, the Alliance has to comply with the request within 7 business days and not 10. Vincent Maltese, Chairman of the GRC stated Murray should not be given any more time to comply with a request than any other custodian of records. The GRC’s phone number is 866-850-0511

View draft findings and recommendations
____________
This is the last in a five-part series of stories on the Union County Alliance and the taxpayer funded campaign piece they publish "Union County Directions Newsletter".

Previosly reported in this series:

Political Graft and the Stenders

Dictionary.com's thesaurus lists words for graft: Kickback, fraud, fix, dishonesty, corruption, con, collusion, and bribe

The publication “Union County Directions” is published by the County of Union through the Union County Alliance (UCA) using tax dollars and county employees. There is a mound of evidence that the publication is being used as campaign literature to promote candidates supported by the Union County Democratic Committee.

The Union County Alliance's (UCA) Newsletter "Directions" was originally a County of Union Newsletter. The county freeholders made the UCA the publisher and gave the money needed to pay for the production and printing to the Alliance. By doing this, the county could side-step the procurement bidding process.

The printing of the first two newsletters were handled by printing broker Richard Stender, d/b/a SVO Printing. Richard was the husband of then sitting Freeholder Linda Stender, who was also on the Board of the Union County Alliance. Stender is currently an assemblywoman and is running for Congress.

Richard was able to charge $20,000 more for each issue he printed than the next highest bidder.

See quotes and invoices mentioned below

PART 1
SVO, owned by Richard Stender, husband of Linda Stender, charged Union County Alliance $31,892.40 for printing and mailing the summer 1999 issue of Directions (see attached invoice E). This was $13,970 more than quoted by Rentec Design Studio, who quoted printing and mailing for $17,920.

The UCA was also charged an additional $634 for film that was not included in SVO’s quote but was in Rentec’s (see attached quote C). Stender also printed the Fall 1999 issue of Directions, this time charging over $18,000 not including the film charge.

For printing the first two issues of Directions, Richard Stender charged UCA over $33,238. The Union County Alliance has claimed that they are exempt from the Open Public Records Act so getting quotes, invoices and records is impossible without their cooperation. Their un-cooperation proves their guilt.

PART 2
In 2001, when Joe Renna was working for the County of Union he obtained a quote to print a 24 page full color version of Directions. AFL quoted the printing and mailing at $26,989. (see attached quote G). Richard Stender quoted the same job for $71,315, over $44,326 more than AFL. (see attached quote H). Concerns raised by Joe Renna about the difference in the cost of printing caused the county to use AFL. Renna was served with termination papers stemming from SVO not getting the contract. In the proceedings, evidence showed that e-mails used as evidence by the county were back-dated. The Judge found the county lacked credibility and ruled in Renna’s favor. The docket numbers for the case are: (OAL DKT NO. CSV 3196-03, Agency DKT. NO. 2003-2371)

Did Assemblywoman Stender try to obtain a contract for her husband?

The content of this newsletter is controlled by the County's Public Information Department. The Union County Watchdog Association (UCWA) argues that the UC Democratic Committee should reimburse the taxpayers for the cost of the newsletters, which are mailed to every postal patron twice a year just days before the primary and general elections, which we believe is a violation of Election Law Enforcement Commission (ELEC) laws.

Mike Murray, who is now the president of the Union County Alliance was originally the director of public information for the county. Just as the current head of public information does, Murray made sure that the candidates up for re-election would be prominently displayed throughout the newsletter. The newsletter would be designed and redesigned to make sure that the Democratic party's selected candidates would be featured. Not only the freeholder candidates but those who could use help in their campaign in local elections as well.

For instance the two covers below show how the Summer 2002 issue of Directions was originally designed and then as it was actually printed. Note that the three freeholders that appear on the cover were the ones who were up for re-election that year. Freeholder Proctor needed a little extra boost since he was running as an incumbent by being appointed to fill a vacancy as most current sitting freeholders were.

Also note how the County of Union removed their name as co-publishers.

Original cover design featuring Senior Citizens:



Cover changed to feature campaigning freeholders:



This is the second in a series of findings. Previously reported:

Rubbing out a Freeholder

When sitting Freeholder Don Goncalves was up for re-election in 1999, he had fallen out of favor with the Union County Democratic Committee and did not get their support for the party line. His image was digitally removed from a photograph that appeared in the Directions Newsletter. This was done so it would not give Goncalves any publicity that may have helped his campaign. The before-and-after photos appear below.

Original photo of incumbent Democrat candidates for Freeholder Chester Holmes, Assembly Candidate Linda Stender, Freeholder Don Goncalves and Union County Alliance Director and Kean University president Henry Ross.



The photo as it appeared in the Directions Newsletter which was mailed to every postal patron before the election with Freeholder Don Goncalves rubbed out. Goncalves’ arm was made to look like it belonged to Ross.



Political campaign mail: An important trust

According to a Postal bulletin dated 10/19/00: (See Bulletin) Any material accepted for mailing at first-Class or Standard Mail (A) postage rates that is mailed for political campaign purposes by a registered political candidate, campaign committee, or committee of a political party is classified as a political campaign mailing.

The Union County Directions Newsletter is sent out tagged “Political” which is a postal designation to ensure campaign mailings get delivered prior to Election Day.

The production of the newsletter, its content and timing is politically motivated as stories and design elements focus on selective candidates. This included a guarantee the newsletter be delivered prior to the day of election. (See guarantee)

A letter to the Elizabeth Post Master from the Union County Alliance asks for a refund of monies in a joint account the Alliance controlled with the County of Union. This account is still being used for the Directions mailings. (See letter)

Even though the Fall 2001 newsletter was produced and ready to go to press the county did not print and mail it because it wouldn’t arrive in mailboxes until after the election.



County Mouthpiece calls mother “Wicked” girlscout “Evil”
The story on the cover of the June 2002 Directions Newsletter featured veterans receiving their high school diplomas. They had to leave high school to serve their country During World War II. A Westfield High School junior selflessly toiled on the project in order to earn her Girl Scout Gold Award.

Aside from using her work to promote campaigning freeholders, did the county appreciate this girl's work?

In an e-mail copied to several employees, including the county manager and deputy county manager, then County Public Information Director Michael Murray writes:

"I was at the last meetings, including the 'emergency meeting' with the evil Girl Scout, her wicked mother and the muted troop leader."

Did any county management defend the girl?

County Manager George Devanney responds to Murray's email:

"OK then, how about just snacks……all in favor????"

View Email

Below: Cover featuring three photos of veterans who served their country during war and five photos of campaigning freeholders. There are no girl scouts mentioned or pictured on the cover. They aren't mentioned until paragraph 13 on page 11. Which is seven paragraphs after Freeholder Mingo states, "I was very proud that I helped bring about today's events...:

August 05, 2006

Trust fund grants show signs of propaganda



Imagine if your town council launched an image building campaign at taxpayer’s expense. They would pay a consultant $45,000 to brand their image on everything including signage on all town buildings and town property, including vehicles that would read “This is a service of your town council, we’re connected to you!” You’d also have to pay for the signs, about 1-million dollars worth just to get started.

The entire town council would be run out of office on the next Election Day. If not sooner by taxpayers trying to impale them with these very signs.

So where did the County of Union get this idea from and why are taxpayers putting up with it? I can’t explain why taxpayers put up with anything, although I think it has mostly to do with most people not even bothering to vote anymore, but I can tell you where they got the idea from.

In the spring of 1999 Message & Media of New Brunswick was awarded a $45,000 contract to design new county signs. The firm was hired to implement “a new graphic and thematic image devoted to projecting a new identity” for Union County. It was a part of the county’s “Image Building Campaign” in which the firm boasted of being responsible for “the branding of the County with the “We’re Connected to You” image. (View Worrall Community Newspaper article regarding signage from 12/99)

The county even hangs these sings on municipal property. All 21 municipalities have sent the county millions in Open Space Trust fund monies since the fund’s adoption. The county in-turn has sent back one time payments of a few measly thousand dollars in the form of Open Space grants. You can’t miss where this money has gone. The county gives out these grants in October – right before Election Day and makes sure they have plenty of press releases about it in your local paper.

You’ll also see a county sign hanging where the money was spent even though your town has to match the grant’s funds in order to receive it. You can’t get county trust fund monies without signing an agreement with the county which includes agreeing to hang a “We’re connected to you!” sign. There is no stipulation in the agreement which states when you can take the sign down but you do have to agree to have the county install it “for you!” exactly where “they want it to hang!”.

The agreement states:

Upon execution of this agreement, the Municipality consents to the placement of a sign that reads, “Greening Union County/Kids Recreation Trust Grant Program/Preserve Union County”. A Service of the Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders. You’re Trust Fund Dollars at Work for you!” Signage shall be designed and installed by Union County’s Bureau of Traffic and Maintenance. (View agreement template)

This Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders advertising at taxpayer’s expense is priceless to the all-Democrat ruled freeholder board. Along with the photo ops at election time, consider the cost of bill board advertising.

The town of Cranford has bill boards on the perimeters of their downtown. Some of these billboards hang on quite streets. The standard advertising rate for a non profit is $525.00 per bill board per month plus the paper which costs $85 a poster. The private sector rate is $1,600.00 a month.

The county doesn’t miss a chance to hang a sign on anything. Nothing is sacred or off limits to their propaganda.

August 04, 2006

Freehholder Franking???...Get Real

Recently, I referred to the Union County Alliance newspaper, “Union County Directions”, as a taxpayer funded political campaign piece to promote Union County’s Democrat public officials who are up for reelection. Of course this always draws criticism from the GOP's opponents who staunchly defend the county’s use of public money with the justification that the publication is merely intended to “inform” county residents of what is going on in the county and alerting residents of the various useful services that the county provides.

Timing being everything there are those who point to congressional mailings from legislators, one of which arrived a couple of weeks ago, as being the exact same thing and why is it that I don’t denounce the Republicans as being guilty of the same abuse of tax payer dollars.

Well, that is because there is a difference, namely "franking”.

According to the Committee on House Administration website, http://cha.house.gov/services/franking_commission_whatisfrank.htm

In 1775: “The American Continental Congress authorized franking privileges to its members as a means of informing their constituents. The first U.S. Congress enacted a franking law in 1789. The franking privilege has remained a necessary and valuable tool of our representative government for more than 200 years.”

By investigating further an interested voter can learn that congressmen and senators are given an annual budget to use at their discretion for specific expenses one of which is called “constituent mailings”.

All mass mailings are to be approved by the Franking Commission and bear the notation:“This mailing was prepared, published and mailed at taxpayer expense” and must hit mailboxes at least 90 days prior to an election, no exceptions.

Perhaps GOP detractors can point us in the direction of where to learn, just what are the “special franking privileges” that apply to the Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders?

Seems to me that NJ ELEC laws would apply to them and the entire cadre of Democrat candidates up for reelection or are they exempt?

Do NJ regulations apply only to Republicans?

Let’s get real here.

The Freeholder board sends taxpayer money to the Alliance for the publication of the UC Directions, the publication comes out twice a year, mailed to UC residents arriving just days before both the primary and general elections, it features Democrat incumbents up for reelection, both pictures and articles. Representatives of The Alliance claim that this is just a "coincidence".

NJ ELEC law says that these types of informational pieces, with incumbents, paid for with tax dollars must reach the general public in the district at least 90 days prior to an election. (Exceptions to the rule are response letters to specific individuals and notices of emergency situations which residents must be informed about, further, "Political" mailings are considered to be any communication which talks about the accomplishments of the individuals featured, certainly appears as though the UC Directions is just chock full of that sort of thing,therefore the publication could be considered "Political" and should not be paid for with tax dollars.)

Spelling it out

The Saturday or Monday before Election Day, which is always on a Tuesday is merely two days not three months prior to an election.

Obviously there is either someone who can’t count or the US Postal Service is in even worse shape and slower than we all originally thought.

July 30, 2006

"Not on our watch!"

The recent revelation uncovered by the Union County Watchdog Association that Freeholder Rick Proctor has been appointed by the Union County Democratic Committee and then put on their ballot and elected two times while keeping from the public that he had two complaints filed against him alleging sexual harassment, among other things, has led the UCWA to file an expansive Open Public Records Request.

We find it necessary to conduct an on-site inspection of all complaints, briefs, and settlements for 36 law suits that have shown up on county resolutions in the years 2005 and 2006. View OPRA request

The Star-Ledger can not be trusted


We aren’t quite sure what these law suits allege. What we are now sure of is that “IF” the Union County media knows about these law suits it isn’t informing the public about them. A Star-Ledger reporter knew about the recent Proctor case “months ago” according to an attorney involved, yet hasn’t written a word about it to date. Proctor was sworn in to his new term just “months ago” in January. Also note today’s fluff piece about Assemblywoman Stender’s run for Congress. The Ledger article doesn’t mention a word about her securing lucrative contracts for her husband’s printing firm while she was a freeholder or her present employment with the county.


Above: Public Information Officer D'Elia photographed while taking photo's and harassing women at a polling station on Election Day. D'Elia insisted "I did not take pictures of those women."
The county’s public information officer has been quoted in the Ledger trashing my OPRA requests looking into county business. He’s lamented and lied “by requesting reams of documents she believes she will expose overspending, officials, said, she has forced the government to spend upwards of $100,000.” He then gives a lame accounting, without back-up documentation, to prove his claims of how he arrived at this $100,000 figure.

D’Elia’s salary happens to be just a hair under $100,000 – not including his lucrative “public servant” benefits. Who would the taxpayers rather inform them? The county’s self-serving public disinformation office who are proven liars with obvious connections to muffle the media or the Union County Watchdog Association?

The county can not be trusted

The county tried to cover up this freeholder law suit by excessively redacting executive session meeting minutes as well as broke other rules required by the Open Public Meetings Act. This suit has cost the taxpayers $25,000 to date and it’s just getting started! Proctor is due to give his deposition this week. We propose that the county do away with the entire million dollar a year office of public disinformation – and fetch those documents for the UCWA! We’ve come to that conclusion long ago.

This investigation will produce “reams” of paper; however, on-site inspections don’t require copying unless the requestor specifically asks for them.

I expect the county to counter that this request will “shut down the entire legal department." I propose they shut down the entire county government until taxpayers are informed as to how our officials are conducting themselves and involving us in costly law suits.

Going forward the UCWA will request documents for all new law suits. A freeholder being appointed and elected twice while keeping skeletons in the Star-Ledger’s closet with attorney’s paid for with tax dollars won’t happen again – not on our watch.

July 27, 2006

We'll Have You Processed and On Your Way in JUST ONE MINUTE Mr. Goore



It’s no wonder Goore choose the Elizabeth DMV to restore his license -- It literally only takes a minute to process the paper work.

"This is a service of Freeholder Angel Estrada. I'm connected to you!"

Previously reported in the Bergen Record, Farber said Goore drove her personal car from their North Bergen home to the Elizabeth motor vehicle agency.

Records show that Goore's license was restored at 10:57 a.m. – little more than a half-hour after he left the Fairview checkpoint, according to officials at the Motor Vehicle Commission.

Mapquest estimates the time it takes to travel from the Farber/Goore household to the Elizabeth DMV office at 65 Jefferson Ave. is 29 minutes. (total est. distance: 18.18 miles)

It literally took one minute for Gore to stand in Line with Freeholder Estrada to renew his license.

According to Wally Edge at PoliticsNJ.com:

The MVC has offices in North Bergen, where Goore lives, and also in Irvington, where he works. If Goore, for some reason, didn't want to use the local office in North Bergen (located 1.37 miles from his home), the MVC has seven offices closer to his home than Elizabeth: Jersey City, Lodi, Englewood, Wallington, Newark, East Orange, Bayonne. If Goore was going during his lunch hour (he works for the Township of Irvington), and didn't (for some reason) want to use the local office located 1/2 mile from his office, he could have made it to East Orange, Newark or Sprinfield faster than Elizabeth.

"I called my friend Angel Estrada. I wanted to tell him that Hamlet was trying to get in touch with him." -- N.J. Attorney General Zulima Farber, who says she called Estrada, a Union County Freeholder and manager of the MVC office in Elizabeth, to tell him that her live-in boyfriend, Hamlet Goore, was coming down to straighten out problems with his drivers license and car registration. Goore stood in line with Estrada. (The Record, 07/23/96)

If we are to believe that this standing in line took place than we would have to believe that it literally took about one minute for Goore to drive home from the checkpoint, arrive in Elizabeth, park his car, greet Farber’s good friend Freeholder Estrada and then stand in Line with him to renew his license.

I would hope the investigation into this incident includes a review of Goore’s EZPASS account and a video review of who stood in line in Elizabeth. I for one won’t be shocked when we’re told the video equipment wasn’t working that day. Faulty video equipment is a common occurrence in Union County.

Gore was lucky Estrada was at the office and not traveling on official business that day:

July 25, 2006

Freeholder Rick Pric-tor
Appointed and elected twice with no mention of abusive history



Five years ago, before the Union County taxpayers were stuck picking up the tab of what is shaping up to be yet another expensive employee law suit due to mismanagement and juvenile behavior, this one involving Freeholder Rick Proctor and his aforementioned private part, a complaint was filed in Essex County on August 23, 2000 against Rick Proctor for the same appendage, among other individuals.

Since then Rick Proctor has been appointed a Union County Freeholder and elected twice without a mention of either of these complaints reported in the media.

Plaintiffs Gina Behre and Barbara Kozak filed the complaint against Township of Bloomfield and the Board of Health. Rick Proctor was the Director of Health and Human Services for the Township of Bloomfield.

During their employment with Defendant Township of Bloomfield, plaintiffs allege that they were subject to a hostile working environment and a pattern of gender, age and pregnancy discrimination. Defendants repeatedly subjected plaintiffs and other female employees to egregious and outrageous acts of a sexually offensive nature within the workplace, which created a pervasive hostile working environment for Plaintiffs and other employees, examples of the discrimination include, but are not limited to, the following:

On or about Summer 1998, defendant Zawacki, who was at the time a passenger in an automobile along with defendant Proctor, told plaintiffs to get in the automobile and “sit on our laps”….

On or about October 7th through December 23, 1998 defendant Proctor without justification hired a private investigator to follow and investigate plaintiffs and other female employees and investigate their personal telephone conversations. No such investigation was conducted of similarly situated male employees or male employees who were younger than plaintiff Kozak.

On or about June 1995 and on numerous other occasions, defendant Wardrope paraded through the office with pornographic materials, including but not limited to, photographs of male genitals.

Notwithstanding plaintiffs’ repeated complaints to defendant Proctor, defendant Wardrope repeatedly and continuously used vulgar gestures and language, ridiculed plaintiffs, and used profanity and language with sexual connotation, particularly the expressions, “F---You”, “C—t”, “Whore”, “Slut” and referred to defendant Proctor as “Mr. Pric-tor” in the presence of plaintiffs and other employees.

On or about January 8, 1999, defendant Proctor uttered negative and derogatory comments to plaintiff Behre in the presence of staff regarding her impending maternity leave and pregnancy.

On or about January 8, 1999, defendant Proctor promoted a male individual who was less experienced and less qualified than plaintiffs. Indeed, the individual had no license to conduct, much less supervise, the duties and responsibilities of a sanitary inspector.

This hiring practice is rampant throughout Union County government from the County Manager on down.

View the complaint

Previously reported:
JULY 21, 2006
Dontcha Wish Your Girlfriend Was Hot Like Me?
Freeholder Rick Pric-tor in jealous workplace triangle: lawsuit
BY TINA RENNA

View the complaint

July 24, 2006

GOP Criticism of 'Directions' Spurred by Watchers Posts

In today's Star-Ledger, Union County Democrats deny that their Union County Directions newsletter - a publication featuring elected officials that is mailed to voters at around election time - is not political at all.

You can read the article, including a quote from our own blogger Pat Quattrocchi, who's runninng for freeholder, here.

Missing from the Ledger article is the fact that the latest Directions featured a screed by Sen. Raymond Lesniak, D-Elizabeth, against the Elizabeth Board of Education, which is stacked with opponents of Mayor Chris Bollwage and Lesniak.

If the newsletter is not political, then why is Sen. Lesniak blasting his political opponents?

If the newsletter is not partisan then why wasn't Elizabeth school board stalwarth Rafael Fajardo, who was accused by the pot (read Lesniak) of being black with corruption, given a chance to respond in the same publication?

Please. If that newsletter isn't political then grits ain't grocery and Paris Hilton is a classy broad.

July 21, 2006

Dontcha Wish Your Girlfriend Was Hot Like Me?
Freeholder in jealous workplace triangle: lawsuit

Are you young and sexy? Than don’t apply for a job with the county’s LINCS program where the boss is allegedly the jealous lover of a married freeholder!

Applicants at least 70 years old, and live out of county, need only apply. And being related to a freeholder or another county politician is also a plus.

In documents obtained using the Open Public Records Act, the Union County Watchdog Association has learned that a law suit was filed in Superior Court of Passaic County by a perspective county employee way back on January 26, 2005.

The UCWA found out about this suit only because it filed a complaint with the Government Records Council and the County Prosecutor's Office charging that the county routinely excessively redacts their executive meeting minutes.

Executive Session Minutes dated February 10, 2005 obtained by the UCWA had an item which only stated that a redaction was due to attorney-client privilege. The minutes the county turned into the GRC in response to our complaint showed: Alyssa Scala v. The County of Union, v. Rick Proctor, v. Denise Santiago.

Intrigued by a freeholder as well as a county employee being named in a law suit which apparently the county went to pains of keeping out of the public eye, the UCWA figured it had better keep digging.

Dig it

Alyssa D. Scala alleges in her complaint:

In July 2003, Ms. Scala worked for the Township of Union with the title of Health Educator/Risk Communicator for the Union County LINCS. In her position Ms. Scala trained local emergency responders to protect themselves from, and recognize the signs of, terrorist attacks using biological and chemical agents.

The Union County LINCS is a central network of health departments designed to protect the public and first responders from terrorist attacks. The program is funded by a Federal grant.

The county takes over LINCS

In March 2004, the county began negotiating with the Township of Union and the state of New Jersey to assume all control of the LINCS that was being administered by the town.

At several meetings Freeholder Rick Proctor and Denise Santiago told employees that they would keep together the entire LINCS team and offer employment with the county to all LINCS team members. (There is no specification of physical attributes or age restrictions but plantiffs had to reside in Union County.) Ms. Scala relocated from her home of Wayne in Passaic County to a $1,400 a month rental in Westfield on July 16, 2004.

The State approved the county’s takeover of LINCS on August 13, 2004.

The young and sexy need not apply

On August 17, 2004 Ms. Scala received a letter from the county informing her that she would not be hired.

Ms. Scala alleges that she asked Denise Santiago why she wasn’t being hired as promised. In response, Santiago informed Scala that she wasn’t hired due to an administrative decision to hire a 10-hour-per-week Health Educator/Risk Communicator for the LINCS program. Instead of hiring Scala the county filled the position with Lorraine Kowalski, a 70-year old resident of Morris County.

There are two other Kowalski’s on the county payroll:
Freeholder B.J. Kowalski, and
John Kowalski, Public Safety

As the county turns

Scala alleges in her complaint that she later learned that the county did not hire her because Santiago viewed her as a rival for the affections of Freeholder Rick Proctor. Freeholder Proctor was intimately involved not only with Santiago but with the LINCS takeover negotiations.

Scala further alleges that it is an open secret that Defendant Denise Santiago and Defendant Rick Proctor have and/or had an ongoing romantic relationship that remains secret due to the Defendant Rick Proctor’s marriage to another woman.

The allegations continue by Scala… Defendant Denise Santiago expressed her sexual jealousy of Plaintiff by telling others that, among other things, Defendant Rick Proctor looked suggestively at Plaintiff and that Santiago envied Plaintiff’s youth and physical attributes.

Scala who was 33-years old when she applied for the position, alleges that despite her qualifications for the position she was denied employment by the county and soon afterward the county hired a 70-year old woman who Denise Santiago did not view as a sexual rival for the attention of Freeholder Rick Proctor.

The potential bill this drama will cost the taxpayers:

County resolutions show that $25,000 has been appropriated for this suit to date.

Scala seeks compensatory damages, punitive damages, attorney’s fees, costs of suit, pre- and post-judgment interest, all other relief that the Court deems equitable and just.

Scala, you go girl!

View the complaint

July 19, 2006

County Mouthpiece Calls Girlscout 'Evil,' Mother 'Wicked'...

The story on the cover of the June 2002 Directions Newsletter featured veterans receiving their high school diplomas. They had to leave high school to serve their country During World War II. A Westfield High School junior selflessly toiled on the project in order to earn her Girl Scout Gold Award.

Aside from using her work to promote campaigning freeholders, did the county appreciate this girl's work?

In an e-mail copied to several employees, including the county manager and deputy county manager, then County Public Information Director Michael Murray writes:

"I was at the last meetings, including the 'emergency meeting' with the evil Girl Scout, her wicked mother and the muted troop leader."

Did any county management defend the girl?

County Manager George Devanney responds to Murray's email:

"OK then, how about just snacks……all in favor????"

View Email

Below: Cover featuring three photos of veterans who served their country during war and five photos of campaigning freeholders. There are no girl scouts mentioned or pictured on the cover. They aren't mentioned until paragraph 13 on page 11. Which is seven paragraphs after Freeholder Mingo states, "I was very proud that I helped bring about today's events...:



Next up: The Union County Alliance - Let the sunshine in!